Abstract

MARQUEZ SCOTTI, Clara  and  VILARO LUNA, Ignacio. Resistance to the Strong Program in the Sociology of Knowledge: Scientific Asepsis and the Threat of Relativism. Rev. mex. cienc. polít. soc [online]. 2014, vol.59, n.221, pp.77-97. ISSN 0185-1918.

In this article we defend the plausibility of adopting a Strong Program in the Sociology of Knowledge. We critically analyze various objections against it; in particular, we show that the auto-refutation charge is not decisive. We offer a Mertonian hypothesis to explain the reason why the Strong Program continues to be the target of very passionate attacks and mockery, despite its prima facie attractiveness and its affinity with contemporary epistemology. Such hypothesis suggests that at least some of the passionate arguments against the Strong Program are motivated by outrage occurring as a result of the violation of a central value of scientific endeavor.

Keywords : sociology of knowledge; strong program; relativism; Merton; Sokal; Bricmont.

        · abstract in Spanish     · text in Spanish     · Spanish ( pdf )