SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.15 número29Explorando el Faro de El Morro de San Felipe: prácticas profesionales y colaboración académica para la conservación del patrimonio cultural inmueble en el Viejo San Juan, Puerto RicoLa creación de la Sala del Pueblo Sami en el Museo Nacional de las Culturas del Mundo de la Ciudad de México índice de autoresíndice de materiabúsqueda de artículos
Home Pagelista alfabética de revistas  

Servicios Personalizados

Revista

Articulo

Indicadores

Links relacionados

  • No hay artículos similaresSimilares en SciELO

Compartir


Intervención (México DF)

versión impresa ISSN 2007-249X

Intervención (Méx. DF) vol.15 no.29 México ene./jun. 2024  Epub 19-Nov-2024

https://doi.org/10.30763/intervencion.298.v1n29.77.2024 

Academic reports

Recent Experiences with the Production of Temporary Exhibitions. Practices, Approaches, and Perspectives on the Collective Work at the Museo del Área Fundacional from Mendoza, Argentina

*Museo del Área Fundacional de Mendoza, Argentina. mari.marengo84@gmail.com

**Instituto de Arqueología y Etnología, Universidad Nacional de Cuyo (UNCuyo), Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET), Argentina. lorenaivanapuebla@gmail.com

***Centro de Investigaciones Ruinas de San Francisco, Área Fundacional de Mendoza, Argentina. karinasilvana.cg@gmail.com


Abstract

The present contribution systematizes our working experiences, since 2018, regarding the production and planning of a cycle of temporary exhibitions in the Museo del Área Fundacional (MAF, Foundation Area Museum) in Mendoza, Argentina, whose topics had a historical context. From the theoretical-methodological perspective of research-action-creation, we developed three temporary exhibitions, marked by certain definitions surrounding the addressed subjects and the museological proposal. In this sense, new questions, contents, and objectives were posed, such as highlighting social sectors which had been absent from the MAF museal narrative, as well as a communication proposal striving to reach a broader public.

Keywords: museological exhibitions; collective work; exhibitions; museum publics; museological experiences; history

Resumen

Esta contribución sistematiza experiencias de trabajo en torno de la producción y planificación, desde 2018, de un ciclo de exposiciones temporales con temáticas de contenido histórico en el Museo del Área Fundacional (MAF) de Mendoza, Argentina. Desde la perspectiva teórica-metodológica investigación-acción-creación, se concretaron tres exposiciones temporales, que estuvieron signadas por algunas definiciones alrededor de los temas abordados y de la propuesta museológica. En ese sentido, se plantearon nuevos interrogantes, contenidos y objetivos, como la visibilización de sectores sociales ausentes en la narrativa museal del MAF y el planteamiento de una búsqueda comunicacional para llegar a públicos más amplios.

Palabras clave: exposiciones museológicas; trabajo colectivo; exposiciones; públicos de museos; experiencias museológicas; historia

Introduction

The Museo del Área Fundacional (MAF) is an institution that depends on the municipality and is located in Pedro del Castillo square (in the Fourth Section of the City of Mendoza, Argentina), which used to be the Plaza Mayor (Main Square) of this city, founded in 1561. It was inaugurated in 1993 following a research process launched by the municipal authority that gave historical, urban, and heritage value to that part of the city.

The MAF is an archeological site museum that contains architectural remains of the buildings that operated consecutively in this location since the early 17th century and up until the 1980s: the former Colonial Council, the town slaughterhouse (after the 1861 earthquake), and later the municipality fruit and vegetables market (Bárcena & Schávelzon, 1991). The 1861 earthquake completely destroyed the city and represented a watershed in its urban configuration. Mendoza was reconstructed around its current location (towards the southwestern sector), while the old city and its inhabitants suffered a process of marginalization, impoverishment, and neglect.

Since 1998, the Centro de Investigaciones Ruinas de San Francisco (CIRSF) is charged with studying and rescuing the history of this foundational sector of the city through the work of its team of urban archeologists. This Center and the MAF work together to research, conserve, and disseminate the heritage of the city and its inhabitants. The Museum offers its visitors the opportunity to observe how history is recovered in its different stages, linked to the archaeological remains it houses and protects. The musealized heritage comes from its own collections (purchases and donations) as well as from CIRSF’s (archaeological collections obtained through the research process), and also materials on loan from institutions and/or individuals for temporary exhibitions.

The following text is the outcome of a process of exchanges, searches, and concerns voiced by the authors, who are female researchers, archaeologists, and historians, but also colleagues and friends that share tasks in the Foundation Area. In 2018, we formed a collective with the aim of carrying out temporary exhibitions to highlight social sectors which are absent from the mu seum’s current permanent script in particular, and, in general from, the narrative of history museums in Mendoza. We collectively and consensually held three temporary exhibitions with common denominators, created from a previously agreed theoretical-methodological framework and a gender perspective, whose themes were centered around women and/or children in Argentina and in Mendoza spanning the last third of the 19th century and the first decades of the 20th.

It is worth mentioning that the MAF does not include an area destined to temporary exhibitions, hence they were displayed in the permanent collection called Paisajes en Pugna, which houses exhibits that address the immediate and long-term effects of the 1861 earthquake, and the ensuing geographic and socio-cultural division between the Old City and the New City of Mendoza (Marengo & Puebla, 2023).

These temporary exhibitions were set up in an integral way, in dialogue with the historical contents and museographic guidelines of the collection, and coinciding with the timeline therein. After the exhibits were taken down, they became travelling exhibitions composed of museographic materials that adapt to the characteristics of the spaces where they are sent.

A starting point

Our work is sustained by the contribution of different theoretical and methodological frameworks. We began with the link between research-action, understood as a transformation process of social problems (Lewin, 1992). To this we added the Latin American point of view of Fals Borda (1998) on Research-Participative Action, which proposed to overcome the lexicon of academia and reflect on a sentipensante (sensing/thinking) knowledge that serves the interests of exploited groups. At the same time, the research prioritized the collective way in which knowledge is produced (Calderón & López, 2013). Lastly, we examined the work Action Research-Artistic Creation (IACA) carried out by Huertas Barbosa and Vanegas Arias (2018), who propose a research process of creation/training where teachers of different arts hold dialogues of knowledge with the communities they work with. We took the concept of research spiral from the latter authors (Huertas & Vanegas, 2018, p. 41), wherein actors and stages in the process interrelate in a dialogic manner. To highlight the museological aspect, we believe the exhibition process constitutes a creative act, “insofar as it seeks to convey that which is absent based on a few, partial, elements of this complexity. Said process is also creative in the sense that it can generate new knowledge and experiences in the receptors exposed to the discourse: in the visitors1(Arrieta, 2015, p. 13).

Our work is guided by concerns regarding the interests, worries, and needs of specific sectors of the community,2 mainly those who are unable to access the Museum due to various difficulties. An other crucial point is the socialization of our research. The exhibitions created by our collective travel to different educational institutions in the city of Mendoza, where, through popular educational workshops, we strive to establish a dialogue with the community. This is in accordance with Paulo Freire’s proposal (1970), the decolonial pedagogies (Walsh, 2007), and the systematization of experiences (Jara, 2012), from a feminist pedagogical perspective (Korol, 2007).

We adhere to Community Feminism (Cabnal, 2010; (Guzmán, 2015) while striving to build our feminist genealogies (Ciriza, 2015): our starting point is situated knowledge by problematizing ob jectivity (Haraway, 2013). This perspective questions the desire and possibility of actually achieving objectivity in science, as well as discussing:

[…] the relationship that is established between the person who knows and what is known, between the researcher and the person researched; criticizes the use of objectivity as a patriarchal means of control, the emotional detachment and the supposition that there is a social world that can be observed externally from peoples’ conscience […]3 (Blazquez et al., 2010, p. 26).

With these ideas, we consider that museums are neither neutral nor apolitical, but rather, on the one hand, they reflect, dissem inate, and reinforce gender stereotypes through a sexist construction and use of knowledge (Maceira, 2017), while on the other, they advertise vision where gender roles have been immutable and sim ilar in all cultures throughout history, without abandoning the binary scheme.

A similar process occurs with the theme of childhood: during the past three decades, the field of historiography has extended to children and families, thus enabling new lines of research (Sosenski, 2023, p. 275). However, the sources used and the predominant visions in the narratives remit to the concept of childhood as a stage of human life that is naturalized, stereotyped, and depicted from the adult’s perspective (Pelegrinelli & Tabakman, 2020).

We choose to affirm there is not “one childhood”, but rather many, and that being a girl or boy are different experiences which frame vital situations and, hence, develop differently according to each historical, familial, social, cultural, economical, and political context. Childhoods have changed over time and space, and the way we understand and address them has also been modified (Carli, 1999).

We believe there is an urgent need for the MAF museology to incorporate perspectives which render the stories more complex, establish a critical attitude towards the traditional exhibition discourses, as well as break with androcentric gender roles and adult-centered viewpoints and shun the stereotypes that lead to discriminatory attitudes (Prados, Izquierdo, & López, 2013, p. 113).

From our place of work, we agree with the tenets of critical museo logy, which uphold that the museum “has a moral responsibility towards all the members of the society it claims to serve. However, this is not only the institution’s responsibility, it includes the people who work there, since they are the ones who serve as vehicles to propagate a certain social imaginary…”4 (Navarro, 2011, p. 53).

Methodology

The stages of the work we developed in the three exhibitions were: 1) collective research, 2) creating the museological script, 3) creating the museographic script, 4) systematizing experiences, and 5) itinerance (Figure 1).

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2018-2023; source: authors' collection)

Figure 1 Various stages of the work. 

1) Collective research

The work group comprises the three authors. Therein lies the collective, all three of us consented to the work process; we took decisions jointly and participated in all the stages in a coordinated manner. We held regular meetings to dialogue and reflect in order to define each exhibition’s objectives, problems, and main axes. In that regard, we chose to address themes that are not covered in the MAF permanent script, but are linked to the history of the city and in particular to the place where the Museum is located. Thus, we aimed to complexifying insight andstrain the historical account the institution sets forth, by adding new narratives and interpretations (Mieri, 2015, p. 133). This stage also foresaw searching for primary sources, photographs, historical advertisements5 in repos itories, newspaper archives, and provincial libraries, as well as reading and analyzing bibliographic background.

2) Creating the museological script

The resulting historical research is organized by means of text panels with a maximum of 300 words per panel. This length is justified by one of the premises of thematic interpretation that states that “it is relevant to be brief” for two reasons, one is related to the public’s attention span, and the other being that brief texts offer the pos sibility of greater space for design and images (Mosco, 2018, p. 157).

At the same time, we selected images to illustrate the content or serve as triggers for memories or emotions. We also sought fragments of poems, popular sayings, or songs by Latin Amer ican artists as titles for the texts.6 We worked with the Museum’s Docu mentation and Registry of Collections department and with the CIRSF to search for materials and objects which could be displayed, though we prioritized the inclusion of elements provided by the team working in the foundation area. The curatorial criterion adop ted for the list of works that would form part of the exhibition was, primarily, to prioritize the cultural biography of objects,7 working towards the intimate stories that express them with regards to the people who donated or lent these objects, or the experiences they could generate in the visitors of the exhibition (Figure 2).

(Photographs: María Marengo ,2023; source: authors' collection)

Figure 2 Musealized objects and their histories. Exhibition Esos locos bajitos… Infancias inmigrantes en Argentina (end of the 19t h -early 20 th centuries)

We selected the room and designed the museographic proposal in that space, taking into consideration the order of text panels, museographic supports, the expected route and the interactive activities. It is important to add that we favored an autonomous route, so visitors can explore it at their own pace and get involved, intervene, or stop at the aspects they find most interesting or appealing. Furthermore, we wish to generate emotions, sensations, and affective or empathic links in the visitors, as well as connections with their stories and circumstances, beyond their possible acquisition of conceptual contents. Therefore, the exhibitions have established sectors for public participation (Figure 3). In addition, we created pedagogical material for the reception staff and Mu seum guides, and we also urge the educational institutions to carry out didactic activities.

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2023; source: authors' collection)

Figure 3 A few proposals for participation by the visitors. Exhibition Esos locos bajitos… Infancias inmigrantes en Argentina (end of the 19 th -early 20 th centuries)

3) Creating the museographic script

This stage is extremely important to us, since we believe there should be dialogue and mutual construction between the museological and museographic scripts, to avoid an abrupt cut between the end of one stage-the concept-and the beginning of an other-setting it up-(Galindo, 2018). For the design and montage of the exhibition, we coordinated with the municipality press area for the graphics, and with the Museum’s maintenance team to help set up what had been planned. It is our decision, as a working collect ive, to be directly involved in this stage:8 liaising with other areas; placing each expositive point; establishing the parameters for the font and size of the texts; specifying the colors; reconditioning or creating stands and showcases; setting up the collection and defining an aesthetic that unifies the temporary exhibition and bridges the permanent one. To reinforce this idea, we used the origami9 technique to create interventions in showcases, and the museography for each exhibition (Figure 4). This involvement allowed us to reinforce what Juan Manuel Garibay (2013) calls the “poética museográfica” (poetics of museography) in each exhibition, understanding that:

[...] in an exhibition, we are not only in a theoretical plane, but an experiential one; that is to say, it may propose a consistent theoretical universe which will undoubtedly include essential and highly important elements; however, if it lacks a temporary space framework that activates the conceptual aspect, it will simply not operate as an exhibition, but as theory alone. And in that case… why go to an exhibition? Better stay home and read10 (Garibay, 2013, p. 4).

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2018-2023; source: authors' collection)

Figure 4 Aesthetic aspects. Use of color, historical images and decoration with origami. 

4) Systematization of experiences

This refers to an exchange of points of view on the exhibition, where we analyze possible modifications or corrections, if needed. For this, we consider it vital to have the support of the museum staff, since they are the ones directly linked to the public.

After the dismantling and during the meetings to reflect, systematization, and analysis of the experience, we shared and collected the visitors’ interventions and their participation in the proposed activities, in addition to the feelings and personal sensations of the museum team. To complement and add different points of view, we sought feedback from colleagues and peers, as well as staff at MAF and CIRSF. We gathered these testimonials and evidence to develop a report for the Directorate of the Museum, to be used as consultation material for future articles for dissemination and publication.

5) Itinerance

As mentioned above in the methodological proposal, it is highly important to offe the exhibition to different organisms and institutions in the province, mainly educational institutions that train teachers which are geographically distant from the center of Mendoza and have socioeconomic problems related to the themes covered in this paper11 (Figure 5).

(Photographs: 2022; source: authors’ collection)

Figure 5 Itinerance of exhibitions in public institutions of learning in Mendoza province. A and B) Exhibition Infancias. Postales de la vida de niños y niñas en tiempos modernos (end of the 19 th -early 20 th centuries) in Vera Peñaloza IES, department of San Carlos (2022); C) Exhibition Las huellas de la historia en el cuerpo de las mujeres, in CEBJA 3062, department of Tupungato (2022). 

Experiences

In this section, we develop an analysis of the transversal elements and experiences surrounding the three exhibitions held. The inform ation is summarized in the following table (Figure 6).

(Table: María Marengo, Karina Castañar, & Lorena Puebla, 2024)

Figure 6 Synthesis of information about the three exhibitions held. 

Exhibition Las huellas de la historia en el cuerpo de las mujeres 12

This exhibition entailed an intense archival work searching for historical publications, both in virtual archives (gathering advertisements in the national publication Caras y Caretas) as well as in the San Martin General Public Library (for magazines from Mendoza). The search axis was prescriptive images and social, aesthetic, and fashion norms for women in the period covered.

As for the museological script, in addition to the brevity of text and accessible language on the panels, we prioritized the use of historical photographs. A special contribution was the use of a book used to register sexual workers at that time, which was replicated to broach the current oppression of female bodies, in local code.

One of the most challenging aspects, which we approached with particular emphasis, was to incentivize the public to experience situ ations that appeal to them, that put them in another one’s shoes and, thus, live tangible aspects of the history present in our proposal. In this first exhibition we developed an installation with the aim of highlighting and creating discussion on the current oppressions of female bodies (Figure 7).

Figure 7 Panoramic view of the exhibition Las huellas de la historia en el cuerpo de las mujeres 

Exposición Las huellas de la historia en el cuerpo de las mujeres
Exhibition period Objetives Panels and themes Exposed materials Decoration Public activities
November 2018 to March 2019

  • -Raise awareness about the cultural, social, political and health oppressions historically exercised by patriarchy on women’s bodies

  • -Make visible the mechanisms implemented to control, discipline, make invisible, exclude and determine their role in society

  • -Recognize their forms of resistance

1

  • 2 panels

  • Topics:

  • -Social roles, constructed stereotypes, moral values and mandates towards women at the end of the 19th century and beginning of the 20th century

  • -The repressive and regulatory policies that were imposed on their bodies

Materials from the MAF collections

  • -Origami butterflies in purple, in display cases and pendants

  • -Footprints and red women’s shoes indicating the circulation circuit on the floor

  • -Installation:

  • You look at yourself? do you like yourself?

  • -Table with supplies to apply makeup with rice powder and mirror

  • -Coat rack with clothes and hats

Exposición Infancias. Postales de la vida de niños y niñas en tiempos modernos (finales del siglo XIX-principios del siglo XX)
Exhibition period Objetives Panels and themes Exposed materials Decoration Public activities
Between August and December 2019

  • -Make visible the diversity of experiences that exist in relation to childhood

  • -Recognize how childhoods are influenced by their historical, family, social, cultural, economic and political context

12 panels Topics: -The image of childhood in school textbooks -Games and toys -Children’s health -Childhood as an object of advertising -The first children’s publications -Gender roles and stereotypes -Rural and urban childhoods -Infant death -Orphan childhoods and child labor -The role of education in the consolidation of the Argentine State -Materials from the MAF collections and loans from workers in the Foundation Area -School books and supplies -Toys -Folded paper garlands, paper flowers that connect paneling and display cases -Hopscotch on the floor -Coat rack with costumes for childhood -Exhibition room blackboard with instructions to leave a message in a notebook
Exposición Esos locos bajitos… Infancias inmigrantes en Argentina (end of the 19thearly 20th centuries)
Exhibition period Objetives Panels and Themes Exposed materials Decoration Public activities
Between July and December 2023. - Offer visitors a critical review of the period of mass European immigration in Argentina -Complete and make the stories about mass immigration more complex -Put the focus on immigrant childhoods and de-romanticize discourses on the subject -Link and extend the view towards current migrations

  • 12 panels

  • Topics:

  • -The circumstances of migrant childhoods through written testimonies and photographs

  • -Childhoods and the adventures of their boat trip

  • -Socialization and schooling

  • -Child labor in the countryside and the city

  • -Stories and life stories

  • Materials from the MAF collections, loans from workers in the Foundation Area and from individuals

  • -Scenes with travel suitcases and various materials: clothes, photographs, travel items

  • -Toys

  • -Elements associated with the railway

  • -Sewing items

  • -School supplies and books

-Folded paper boats in a variety of pastel tones, distributed in the display cases

  • -Invitation to participate in different stations of the route, based on various instructions:

  • -Listen to a “message in the bottle” through a QR code, write a memory and hang it in the designated space

  • -Contribute on a virtual collaborative whiteboard

  • -Sample closing activity

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2018; source: authors' collection).

It comprised a small, enclosed structure or tent with three walls made of mirrors. Within were exhibited national or local publications from the period taken from the printed press, which reproduced prescriptive messages on social norms surrounding beauty ideals, body image, and desirable qualities in women. On the frontal mirror, over the reflected image of the visitor, was a caption: ¿Te mirás? ¿Te gustas? (Do you see yourself? Do you like yourself?) (Figure 8).

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2018; source: authors' collection)

Figure 8 Detail of the installation ¿Te mirás? ¿Te gustás? Exhibition Las huellas de la historia en el cuerpo de las mujeres

After it was dismantled, the exhibition went around institutions of middle and higher education in different departments of the Mendoza province (Maipu, Tunuyan, Tupungato, San Carlos, Godoy Cruz, Las Heras, Lujan de Cuyo, and the city of Mendoza). This exhibition was the most requested for itinerance. At each oppor tunity there were workshops, debates, and group activities with students and teachers.

Exhibition Infancias. Postales de la vida de niños y niñas en tiempos modernos 13 (end of the 19 th -early 20 th centuries)

Particular attention was paid to outlining a historical and critical view on our representations of childhoods in Argentina and Mendoza between the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Said construction was obtained by means of images, photographs, and magazines, as well as historical and archeological materials. The use of textbooks published at the time was another important element in that sense.

As for the museological script, there was great concern about guaranteeing the accessibility to its content both in the cognitive and physical aspects, prioritizing short texts and clearly marked museographic and visual supports. Hence, the height of the display cases and museographic furniture was taken into consideration. We also incorporated QR codes with links to audio about the content of each panel (Figure 9).

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2019-2023; source: authors’ collection)

Figure 9 Aspects related to physical and cognitive accessibility A) Panel with images and QR codes with linked audios; B) and C) Accessible display cases. 

In order to carry out a situated experience, for this exhibition we created a thematic sector called “La muerte de un niño” (Death of a Child). Here, through historical photographs, song lyrics, ambience, and museographic furniture, we referred to certain practices surrounding the death of children in both rural and urban family environments during the period in question (Figure 10).

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2019; source: authors’ collection)

Figure 10 A) Panoramic view of the exhibition Infancias. Postales de la vida de niños y niñas en tiempos modernos (end of the 19 th -early 20 th centuries); B) Thematic sector “The Death of a Child”; C) View of the initial panel in the exhibition Infancias. Postales de la vida de niños y niñas en tiempos modernos (end of the 19 th -early 20 th centuries)

This exhibition has also travelled and has been requested by institutions of higher education in General Alvear and Tunuyan (Mendoza, Argentina).

Exhibition Esos locos bajitos… Infancias inmigrantes en Argentina 14 (end of the 19 th early 20 th centuries)

The search for sources for this exhibition focused on photographs, historical publications in digital archives, and provincial libraries. The curatorial axis was to reconstruct, through presence and testi monies, those childhood experiences during migration processes in the late 19th and early 20th centuries (Figure 11).

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2023; source: authors' collection)

Figure 11 Panoramic of the exhibition Esos locos bajitos… Infancias inmigrantes en Argentina (end of the 19 th -early 20 th centuries)

In addition to QR codes with links to audio referring to each expository space, this last exhibition also included QR codes with the personal stories of people related to certain objects. In this way, we were able to share an anecdote or experience from family life closely linked to the migration process. For example, a suitcase belonging to a worker of the Buenos Aires-Pacific railroad, containing stationery items and railway instruments, told by one of his granddaughters, who rescued the story of her grandfather and his immigrant wife.

This exhibition multiplied the activities and devices to achieve a greater interaction and participation by the public, through messages written on paper where they responded to instructions and by using a collaborative virtual board. One of the devices that generated the most answers was a frame with photographs which invited the public to leave a written memory or anecdote. Over the course of the exhibition, 378 messages were received, including memories, acknowledgements to the museum, and drawings. Of these, 195 were directly linked to the proposed activity, written by both adults and children, with the names of immigrants, anecdotes, places of origin, and destination when migrating, feelings and appreciation of the entire process (Figure 12).

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2023; source: authors' collection)

Figure 12 A proposal for participation by the public, exhibition Esos locos bajitos… Infancias inmigrantes en Argentina (end of the 19 th -early 20 th centuries)

This last exhibition has not travelled yet, but we have a calendar with requests from institutions interested in receiving it in the short-term. Furthermore, a closing activity was held with the participation of people and groups from different cultural collectives that belong to contemporary Mendoza. For example, one academy shared Arab dances and their stories; a book with the biography of a Spanish immigrant was presented, as well as a live interview with an Italian immigrant who came to Mendoza as a child and lived in the MAF neighborhood. Finally, the contributions of the groups of visitors from Institutes of Higher Learning were shown (Figure 13).

(Photographs: María Marengo, 2023; source: authors' collection)

Figure 13 Scenes from the closing activity Esos locos bajitos…Infancias inmigrantes en Argentina (end of the 19 th -early 20 th centuries)

As a reflection on the work process, conceived as a research spiral, we believe the flexibility and feedback with the public has resulted in a greater proximity to our immediate community, its requests and interest in the topics covered. It is not a finished process, but rather one that can be perfected by sustaining the proposal over time, gazing back on what was done to reflect and advance.

Situated reflections and future perspectives

Our entire practice is marked by an empathic vision of the past and those who are invisible in the regional historical discourse. Every resource and image was chosen through emotions and the feelings they stirred in us and we sought to share, with greater or lesser success, with the people linked to the exhibitions. Therefore, we cannot refer to conclusions or discussions, only reflections that stem from what we do as women and researchers in an open and public cultural space located in an area of Mendoza with marginalization, prostitution, and migrants.

The public’s participation gradually increased, not only in quant ity, it also acquired greater prominence within the expository space, completing and improving the exhibited contents. We feel that this path brought us closer to the community, although we have still not effectively reached certain secondary sectors near the Museum. Therefore, we believe it necessary to generate medium and long-term communication and participation mechanisms with the neighborhood, which will become an institutional cultural policy.

The fact that the exhibitions travelled to educational institutions of different levels and socioeconomic contexts challenged us to plan and develop dynamics in accordance with the infrastructure, available resources, types of public, and the expectations of teachers and students themselves. Looking retrospectively at our projects, we observe improvements and significant advances in that regard, foreseeing certain situations and adapting the museographic guidelines and pedagogical strategies.

We believe the methodology we applied significantly contributes to museological work in the province in that it proposes team, interdisciplinary, self-critical work, situated in a concrete community with specific needs and expectations. The challenge, therefore, is to permeate this work model to all the actors involved in the museal institutions, primarily those who are in contact with the public and those who make decisions, so that all their actions are coherent and comprehensive.

Furthermore, in our case, working in a museum of archae ology and history, the ability to empathetically link with the past and its protagonists, fostering multiple narratives and views, is highly appealing. Likewise, we believe it could be a feasible approach to apply in any institution in the city of Mendoza that seeks greater synergy with its immediate community.

The challenge is great for years to come, since we must also address the reality of the spaces we occupy, often with very lim ited budgets and staffing levels that require urgent reinforcement. On the one hand, the participation and identification of immediate neighbors and nearby schools and, on the other, accessibility and inclusion, both in the historical representation and in the visual mediums and materials used.

REFERENCES

Arrieta, I. (Ed.) (2015). El complicado arte de exponer. Procesos y retos museográficos. Universidad del País Vasco [Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea]/Argitalpen Zerbitzua Servicio Editorial. [ Links ]

Bárcena, J. R. y Schávelzon, D. (1991). El cabildo de Mendoza. Arqueología e historia para su recuperación. Argentina, Municipalidad de Mendoza. [ Links ]

Blazquez, N., Flores, F. y Ríos, M. (Coords.) (2010). Investigación feminista. Epistemología, metodología y representaciones sociales. Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México. [ Links ]

Bodei, R. (2013). La vida de las cosas. Amorrortu. [ Links ]

Cabnal, L. (2010). Acercamiento a la construcción de la propuesta de pensamiento epistémico de las mujeres indígenas feministas comunitarias de Abya Yala. Momento de paro. Tiempo de rebelión. Miradas feministas para reinventar la lucha, 116(3), 14-17. [ Links ]

Calderón, J. y López, D. (2013). Orlando Fals Borda y la investigación acción participativa: aportes en el proceso de formación para la transformación. Memoria del I Encuentro Hacia una Pedagogía Emancipatoria en Nuestra América, realizado en el Centro Cultural de la Cooperación Floreal Gorini, 11. [ Links ]

Carli, S. (1999). De la familia a la escuela. Infancia, socialización y subjetividad. Cap. 1: La infancia como construcción social. Santillana. [ Links ]

Ciriza, A. (2015). Construir genealogías feministas desde el Sur: encrucijadas y tensiones. MILLCAYAC. Revista Digital de Ciencias Sociales, 2(3), 83-104. [ Links ]

Fals, O. (1998). Seminario-Taller: metodología y técnicas de la investigación-acción participativa (IAP). Coreducar. [ Links ]

Freire, P. D. (2005 [1970]). Pedagogía del oprimido. Siglo XXI Editores. [ Links ]

Galindo, L. (2018). El guion museológico, una herramienta para la seducción. Revista de Museología, 71. Asociación Española de Museólogos. [ Links ]

Garibay, J. (2013). Museografía: poética y revelación. Gaceta de Museos, 54. Revista del INAH, 4-7. [ Links ]

Guzmán, A. (2015). Feminismo Comunitario-Bolivia. Un feminismo útil para la lucha de los pueblos. Revista con la A, 80(38), 1-3. [ Links ]

Haraway, D. (2013). Simios, cyborgs y mujeres: la reinvención de la naturaleza. Routledge. [ Links ]

Huertas Barbosa, A. V., y Vanegas, L. V. (2018). Investigación acción-creación artística (IACA). Orientaciones metodológicas del arte para el diálogo con comunidades (tesis de licenciatura en Artes Escénicas). Universidad Pedagógica Nacional. http://repository.pedagogica.edu.co/handle/20.500.12209/9387Links ]

Jara, O. (2012). La sistematización de experiencias. Práctica y teoría para otros mundos posibles. Bogotá, Centro Internacional de Educación y Desarrollo Humano, pp. 8-258. [ Links ]

Kopytoff, I. (1991). La biografía cultural de las cosas: la mercantilización como proceso. En Appadurai, A. (Ed.). La vida social de las cosas. Perspectiva cultural de las mercancías. Grijalbo, 89-122. [ Links ]

Korol, C. (2007). Hacia una pedagogía feminista: géneros y educación popular. Editorial El Colectivo: América Libre. [ Links ]

Lewin, K. (1992). La investigación-acción y los problemas de las minorías. En Salazar, M. (Coord.). La investigación-acción participativa: inicios y desarrollos. Editorial Popular. Organización de Estados Iberoamericanos para la Educación, la Ciencia y la Cultura. Sociedad Estatal Quinto Centenario, 13-26. [ Links ]

Llamazares, E. L. (2018). Guía de accesibilidad en museos. Secretaría de Cultura/Presidencia de la Nación. [ Links ]

Maceira, L. (2017). ¿Vestigios para un futuro igualitario? Pensar la educación en los museos arqueológicos desde una perspectiva feminista. En Prados, L. et al. (Eds.), Museos arqueológicos y género. Educando en la igualdad. Universidad Autónoma de Madrid Servicio de Publicaciones. Ministerio de Sanidad, Servicios Sociales e Igualdad, 58-93. [ Links ]

Marengo, M. del C. y Puebla, L. (2023). Proyecto de guion desde niños/as de la historia para niños/as del presente. EducaMuseo, 2, 1-13. Ciecs-Conicet-UNC. [ Links ]

Mieri, M. (2015). Silencios y omisiones: narrando y exhibiendo la historia nacional. En Arrieta, I., El arte de exponer: procesos y retos museográficos. Universidad del País Vasco [Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea], Argitalpen Zerbitzua Servicio Editorial, 129-143. [ Links ]

Mosco, A. (2018). Curaduría interpretativa, un modelo para la planeación y desarrollo de exposiciones. Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia. Ciudad de México, Publicaciones ENCRyM. [ Links ]

Navarro, O. (2011). Ética, museos e inclusión: un enfoque crítico. Museo y Territorio, 4, 49-59. [ Links ]

Pelegrinelli, D. y Tabakman, S. (2020). Módulo 2: Tradiciones y supuestos acerca de la infancia. Curso virtual Museos amigables para la niñez. Un buen anfitrión se fija en los detalles, segunda edición. Área Formación y Redes, dependiente de la Dirección Nacional de Museos y la Dirección Nacional de Gestión Patrimonial, Secretaría de Patrimonio Cultural, Ministerio de Cultura de la Nación. [ Links ]

Prados, L., Izquierdo, I. y López, C. (2013). La discriminación de la mujer: los orígenes del problema. La función social y educativa de los museos arqueológicos en la lucha contra la violencia de género. ICOM CE Digital. Museos, género y sexualidad, 8, 110-117. [ Links ]

Sosenski, S. (2023). Familias e infancias en la historia contemporánea: jerarquías de clase, género y edad en Argentina. I. Cosse (Comp.). Editorial Universitaria. Estudios de Historia Moderna y Contemporánea de México, 65, 275-280. [ Links ]

Walsh, C. (2007). Interculturalidad, colonialidad y educación. Revista Educación y Pedagogía, 48, 25-35. [ Links ]

1Editorial translation.

2The first exhibition we will review was inaugurated to commemorate the International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women, within the framework of the feminist struggle for legal abortion in Argentina.

3Editorial translation.

4Editorial translation.

5Historical advertisements refers to publicity announcements and commercial propaganda of products and services published in the graphic press (magazines and newspapers) of the years covered.

6This resource has been used in all three exhibitions reviewed. For example, we used fragments of songs such as “Con la pelota de trapo…” (by Víctor Jara, Chile) to refer to childhood games; “Pueblos trabajadores, infancias pobres…” (by León Gieco, Argentina) to broach the problem of child labor; and “Sacó papel y tinta, y un recuerdo quizás…” (by Violeta Parra, Chile) to delve into immigration. We also used slogans linked to the feminist movement (and writings by María Elena Walsh and Armando Tejada Gómez (Argentina), among others.

7The biography of objects, or the cultural biography of things—to use Kopytoff’s (Kopytoff in Appadurai, 1991) term—leads us to an approach based on the object’s vital trajectory. This perspective facilitates recounting the multiple and habitual relations we have with objects, recovering the multiple strata of meaning they are stripped of when they are treated as merchandise or mere known entities (Bodei, 2013).

8Regarding the design of expository panels, we worked jointly with the Mendoza municipality design team for them to be in synchrony with our objectives and communication, aesthetic, and accessibility criteria, keeping in mind the Guidelines on access to museums belonging to the Ministry of Education, Culture, Science and Technology of Argentina (Llamazares, 2018).

9Origami is a Japanese technique that consists of folding paper to obtain figures of different shapes. We have incorporated this technique in the exhibitions’ museography, choosing specific designs and colors for each.

10Editorial translation.

11For example, located in agricultural areas with child labor problems, precarious working conditions, and gender violence contexts.

12The Marks of History on Women’s Bodies.

13Childhoods. Postcards of the life of girls and boys in modern times.

14Those Crazy Little Ones… Inmigrant childhoods in Argentina.

Translated by Lucienne Marmasse

Received: January 17, 2024; Accepted: May 07, 2024; Published: July 31, 2024

About the authors

María del Carmen Marengo. University Professor holding a BA in History from the Universidad Nacional de Cuyo (UNCuyo, National University of Cuyo) in Mendoza, Argentina and a diploma in Museology and Curatorship (Universidad Católica de Salta). She has worked at Museo del Área Fundacional de Mendoza (MAF) since 2014 fulfilling various roles: researcher, mainly linked to regional, gender, and childhood history; creation of museographic scripts; graphic design and setting up of exhibitions; audience studies and data analysis; organization, classification and digitalization of Documentary Archive; organization of the Library and newspaper library; design and implementation of pedagogical activities; giving talks and conferences; dissemination work on social media and production of historical audiovisuals, among others.

Lorena Puebla. Holds a BA in History (with a focus on Archaeology) and is currently preparing her doctorate in History (UNCuyo). Professor and researcher at the same institution. She developed research in the MAF’s urban archeology team. She participated in the integral creation of museographic scripts and proposals in the MAF regarding themes linked to history of women and children, as well as other activities of transfer and dissemination of archaeological and historical research.

Karina Castañar. University Professor of History. She works since 2004 in the Centro de Investigaciones Ruinas de San Francisco (CIRSF) and in the Museum, which depends on the Municipal ity of Mendoza, developing tasks such as: research, excavations, study, and analysis of different archeological materials. In the Museum she has worked on the creation of museographic scripts, setting up temporary exhibitions, organizing and classifying the library, designing pedagogical activ ities, giving talks and trainings. She has also been part of the UNCuyo’s historical and archeological research university extension project. She teaches at high school level.

Creative Commons License Este es un artículo publicado en acceso abierto bajo una licencia Creative Commons