nueva página del texto (beta)
Inglés (pdf)
Artículo en XML
Referencias del artículo
Traducción automática
Enviar artículo por email
Citado por SciELO 
Similares en
SciELO 
Permalink
Introduction
The quality of life of medical staff can be influenced by stressful situations that are related to daily professional pressures. The life expectancies of obstetrician surgeons and gynecologists are lower than other medical specialists1 and they are subjected to greater stress2. Pressure is perceived as low among psychiatrists, and the uncertainty factor is high among neurologists3. However, adaptive processes may result in some resilience to the impact of sustained stress4,5.
The spontaneous release of cortisol into plasma is a preparatory response of the organism that allows adaptation to the environment and support for stress situations6. However, the continuous presence of cortisol in plasma may be a risk factor for cardiovascular disease7. Under normal conditions, stress results in allostasis8, a normal response of the body to sustained stress in an attempt to regain homeostasis. If the stressful situation is prolonged, then the organism can undergo so-called allostatic overload9, which can be detrimental to health.
The operating room can be considered a natural model for studying stress and the body's response to stress. Urinary cortisol levels are modified in stressful situations that are associated with surgery. The surgeon-patient dyad is subjected to different but nonetheless intense stress that is represented by the surgical procedure. The present study investigated cortisol levels and their possible relationship to indicators of anxiety among surgeons, patients, and stretcher-bearers.
Methods
The present study employed a transversal, quasi-experimental design. Approval of the experimental protocol was obtained from the Research Committee and Ethics Committee of the Center of Medical Specialties of the State of Veracruz “Dr. Rafael Lucio” (CEMEV), México. Based on the relatively common and safe procedures that were used during surgery, the present investigation was classified by General Health Law and the Official Mexican Standard as Category II. The participants in the study received a detailed explanation of the protocol. Afterward, they signed an informed consent form. The anonymity of all of the participants was rigorously ensured.
Experimental groups
Three groups were formed, based on non-probabilistic convenience sampling (n = 12/group), with the common experience of having simultaneously participated in the same surgical event. All of the volunteers were male, solely in an attempt to maintain homogeneity of the sample.
The control group consisted of stretcher-bearers with prior experience in the operating rooms of the hospital. Their primary task was to take the patients to the operating room. The group of patients underwent their first surgical intervention experience. All of the patients had received a diagnosis of inguinal hernia. Under epidural anesthesia, they underwent Lichtenstein's inguinal plasty technique. The group of surgeons had at least 7 years of experience and participated directly in the surgical event. All of the surgeons were certified by the Mexican Council of General Surgery.
In all three groups, participants with a history of metabolic disease, corticosteroid intake in the past 6 months, anxiolytic drug intake in the past 3 months, or a history of adrenal gland disease were excluded from the study.
Sampling and state-trait anxiety inventory (STAI) application
During surgical procedures, the highest degree of expectation is the preoperative period before surgery. The pre-operative period began at 8:00 AM. Stretcher-bearers who tend the stretchers play a relatively passive role compared with surgeons and patients. These stretcher-bearers follow a plan, but they are aware that unexpected events can occur that would expose them to a high degree of stress. For these reasons, we collected urine samples and applied the STAI during the pre-operative period.
Urinary cortisol
A urine sample was collected in a clean container with volume measurements and without preservatives. The quantitative determination of urinary cortisol was performed using an electrochemiluminescent immunoassay (Elecsys 1010/2010, MODULAR ANALYTICS E170, and COBAS E). The Elecsys apparatus for cortisol analysis is based on the competition principle using a polyclonal antibody that is specifically directed against cortisol. The total duration of the analysis was 18 min. A 20 µl sample was incubated with a specific antibody and a labeled ruthenium complex that was derived from cortisol. Depending on the concentration of the factor to be analyzed in the sample and formation of the respective immune complex, the binding site of the labeled antibody is partially occupied by the factor to be analyzed and partially occupied by the ruthenylated hapten. In the second incubation, after adding streptavidin-coated microparticles, binding of the complex to the solid phase occurs through interaction of biotin and streptavidin. The mixture is aspirated into the measuring cell where the microparticles are magnetically captured on the surface of the electrode. The free substances are removed with ProCell. The application of a voltage to the electrode induces chemiluminescent emission that is measured by a photomultiplier. A calibration curve was generated based on two-point calibration and a curve that was obtained from the bar code of the reagent. The reference values for cortisol that were used in the CEMEV and established by Bayer Diagnostics were in the range of 28.5-213.7 g/dl (78.6-589.6 nmol/L).
STAI
The STAI (n.b., the IDARE is the translated and validated version that is used in Mexico)10 was previously applied successfully among participants of the surgical procedure11. The STAI consists of two self-report scales that are designed to measure anxiety as a present state of anxiety (STAI-S [IDARE-E]) and a trait or personality characteristic (STAI-T [IDARE-R]). The STAI-S measures symptoms of anxiety that a person experiences under a specific situation. The STAI-T measures the frequency with which people usually experience anxiety symptoms as a personality trait. Both scales consist of 20 items that are scored on a Likert scale with four options that range from “not at all” to “too much.” The STAI has high consistency, validity, and reliability (Cronbach's a = 0.83 for the STAI-T subscale and 0.92 for the STAI-S subscale), in which its elements and scales are closely related to the constructs of the instrument. The scores are classified as the following: 20-31 (very low anxiety), 32-43 (low anxiety), 44-55 (moderate anxiety), 56-67 (high anxiety), and 68-80 (very high anxiety).
Both the stretcher-bearers and surgeons completed the STAI during the pre-operative period while being comfortably seated. The patients completed the STAI in their bed before taking any medication as part of balanced anesthesia, with the exception of analgesics when indicated.
Statistical analysis
The urinary cortisol data and scores on the two STAI subscales did not follow a parametric distribution; therefore, the results were compared using Kruskal–Wallis nonparametric analysis of variance (ANOVA; Statistica 7, Statsoft), followed by the Wilcoxon post hoc test. Values of p ≤ 0.05 were considered statistically significant. The Wilcoxon test was chosen due to its ability to compare pairs of data that follow a nonparametric distribution. The results are expressed as the mean ± standard error of the mean. The graphs were generated using Kaleidagraph 4.0 software.
Results
The ages of the subjects in the study were not significantly different among groups (H2 = 3.465, p < 0.177). The mean age of the stretcher-bearers was 38.1 ± 2.907 years (range: 25-50 years). The mean age of the surgeons was 44.3 ± 1.884 years (range: 36-50 years). The mean age of the patients was 39.8 ± 2.396 years (range: 28-50 years). The surgeons had a mean of 16.0 ± 1.969 years of professional experience (range: 7-24 years).
Urinary cortisol
Significant differences were found in urinary cortisol levels among groups (H2 = 7.564, p < 0.023). The lowest cortisol level was found in the group of stretcher-bearers. Urine from patients and surgeons contained higher urinary cortisol levels, which were significantly different between surgeons and stretcher-bearers (Fig. 1).
STAI-S
The Kruskal–Wallis test showed that the scores on the STAI-S were not significantly different among the three groups (H2 = 4.598, p = 0.100). The Wilcoxon post hoc test, which was used to compare data by pairs, detected a significant difference (Fig. 2), in which the group of patients had the highest scores on the STAI-S.
Figure 2 State-trait anxiety inventory-S scores. The nonparametric analysis of variance indicated no significant differences among groups. The Wilcoxon post hoc test detected higher scores in patients than in surgeons (*p < 0.008), with no significant difference between patients and stretcher-bearers or between surgeons and stretcher-bearers
STAI-T
The Kruskal–Wallis test indicated significant differences in STAI-T scores among the three groups (H2 = 6.333, p < 0.042). The surgeons had the lowest STAI-T scores (Fig. 3).
Discussion
The aim of the present study was to measure and compare urinary cortisol and anxiety levels in individuals who were subjected to surgical stress (stretcher-bearers, patients, and surgeons) before the surgical event. The highest concentration of urinary cortisol was found in surgeons. The patients had slightly higher STAI-S scores. The surgeons had the lowest STAI-T scores.
The measurement of urinary cortisol was performed in the 1st h of the morning. In general, the lowest levels of plasma cortisol are detected by midnight, with an abrupt increase in cortisol levels on awakening12. This diurnal increase in cortisol levels is associated with the sleep-wake cycle and consists of an increase in plasma cortisol within the 1st h after awakening, surpassing the previous level at midnight by 50% and lasting for at least 1 h13. This diurnal increase is independent of most daily habits12 and considered an adaptive vestige14 that prepares the individual for everyday contingencies. By the time of the present study (8:00 AM), the cortisol measurements may have still reflected this circadian activity of cortisol levels and thus a preparatory response to stress. The stretcher-bearers had the lowest cortisol levels, which may be related to the burden of stress to which they would be subjected. The stretcher-bearer group is presumably less stressed than patients and surgeons. Cortisol has been considered a marker of stress15, considering other markers that are related to the activity of the autonomic nervous system, mainly catecholamines and their derivatives. In the present study, we did not evaluate activity of the autonomic nervous system. Although there was a significant difference among groups, the levels of urinary cortisol that was found in the present study were within normal limits in the three groups. The highest concentration of cortisol was found in the group of surgeons.
When confronting a threatening situation, the first components that the individual faces are anxiety and fear. To successfully cope with the situation, a fundamental aspect is learning, which gives rise to an emotional process that ultimately leads to the choice of the best coping response. Emotional memory allows an individual to recognize signs of the environment and compare them with previous experiences to select the most appropriate response to resolve the threatening situation16,17. Both processes, learning, and selection of the best response, appear to be regulated by portions of the temporal and frontal lobes and deeper structures, such as the hippocampus and amygdala and their connections to the prefrontal and orbitofrontal cortices18-21, among other connections22. Cortisol can regulate interconnections between the amygdala and medial prefrontal cortex, in which high levels of cortisol exert a strong negative action on these connections23. In the present study, cortisol levels fell within the physiological range, and these levels may be related to a healthy response of the organism. The actions of cortisol mediate suppressive actions in some cases and preparatory actions in others24,25.
Natural stress improves immune function, but prolonged stress is associated with a deregulatory action of the immune system and promotes the inflammatory process26. Despite some beneficial actions of cortisol, a prolonged increase above certain levels can produce negative effects on the body. Some negative effects include high plasma glucose concentrations, high blood pressure, high fluid retention, muscle weakness, obesity, and extreme fatigue.
The activation of regulatory structures of the emotional response and response to threatening situations depend on such factors as the nature of the stressor, the gender of the subject, and particularly prior experience27. In medical students, low levels of cortisol are detected during the day, and high levels occur during the afternoon on the day of scholastic tests and remain elevated even after the test, indicating some adaptive capacity28.
The STAI has been successfully applied among surgeons, demonstrating its sensitivity to the detection of anxiety and showing that stress can produce problems with surgical execution even in a surgical simulator29 and even after “mental” training that is used to reduce stress in young surgeons30. In another study that explored changes in autonomic activity, a strong correlation was found between high levels of autonomic activity and high anxiety scores on the STAI11. In the present study, the scores on the STAI-S and STAI-T indicated that all three groups had very low anxiety to low anxiety, although the group of surgeons had the lowest scores on the STAI-T. Notably, STAI-T measures anxiety as a personality trait. Surgeons seemingly become adapted to the stressful stimulus that is represented by the surgical procedure.
One notable paradox was observed in the present study. The surgeons had the highest levels of cortisol while also having the lowest levels of anxiety on the STAI-T. This indicates that a process of adaptation to the stressful stimulus likely occurred, but cortisol levels remained high. In certain situations and depending on prior experience, a subject can develop resistance to threatening situations and is able to adequately manage such situations, which is known as resilience5. In the long term, these adaptive changes are beneficial for the organism and allow for proper responses to threatening situations31. A clear example is an individual who is at constant risk32, which indicates that in a prolonged stressful situation, the individual is able to adapt to stressful situations and maintain his activity within reasonably acceptable limits.
Surgery is stressful. Although strategies to cope with stress are scarce, establishing structured training for stress management is suggested among surgical students33. A study by the American College of Surgeons found a positive correlation between the number of hours worked and the presence of burnout, particularly for those who worked more than 80 h/week34. The greatest impact of stress depends on the time of exposure and not necessarily on the stressor itself. Therefore, the inclusion of short periods of rest has been recommended35,36. Surgical stress is inevitable, and certain strategies can be developed that minimize perceived stress and maintain work activity within acceptable limits.
Conclusion
Surgeons experience a considerable degree of stress, reflected by biochemical markers of stress (i.e., cortisol), but they appear to develop resilience and the proper management of anxiety. Nonetheless, this does not exclude the possibility that there can be some degree of damage from high cortisol levels in the long term.
