<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?><article xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
<front>
<journal-meta>
<journal-id>1405-0218</journal-id>
<journal-title><![CDATA[Isonomía]]></journal-title>
<abbrev-journal-title><![CDATA[Isonomía]]></abbrev-journal-title>
<issn>1405-0218</issn>
<publisher>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Instituto Tecnológico Autónomo de México; Fontamara]]></publisher-name>
</publisher>
</journal-meta>
<article-meta>
<article-id>S1405-02182024000100006</article-id>
<article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.5347/isonomia.60/2024.661</article-id>
<title-group>
<article-title xml:lang="es"><![CDATA[Seguimiento de normas jurídicas: entre irracionalidad e irrelevancia. Un comentario a la noción de &#8216;inderrotabilidad&#8217; de Jorge Rodríguez]]></article-title>
<article-title xml:lang="en"><![CDATA[Legal Rule-Following: Between Irrationality and Irrelevance. A Comment on Jorge Rodríguez&#8217;s Notion of &#8216;Indefeasibility&#8217;]]></article-title>
</title-group>
<contrib-group>
<contrib contrib-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Scataglini]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[María Gabriela]]></given-names>
</name>
<xref ref-type="aff" rid="Aff"/>
</contrib>
</contrib-group>
<aff id="Af1">
<institution><![CDATA[,Universidad de Buenos Aires  ]]></institution>
<addr-line><![CDATA[ ]]></addr-line>
<country>Argentina</country>
</aff>
<pub-date pub-type="pub">
<day>00</day>
<month>00</month>
<year>2024</year>
</pub-date>
<pub-date pub-type="epub">
<day>00</day>
<month>00</month>
<year>2024</year>
</pub-date>
<numero>60</numero>
<fpage>96</fpage>
<lpage>119</lpage>
<copyright-statement/>
<copyright-year/>
<self-uri xlink:href="http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&amp;pid=S1405-02182024000100006&amp;lng=en&amp;nrm=iso"></self-uri><self-uri xlink:href="http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_abstract&amp;pid=S1405-02182024000100006&amp;lng=en&amp;nrm=iso"></self-uri><self-uri xlink:href="http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?script=sci_pdf&amp;pid=S1405-02182024000100006&amp;lng=en&amp;nrm=iso"></self-uri><abstract abstract-type="short" xml:lang="es"><p><![CDATA[Resumen Critico aquí la idea de Jorge Rodríguez de que el dilema entre irracionalidad e irrelevancia en el seguimiento de normas generales y de normas jurídicas en particular, desaparece o pierde su fuerza si dejamos de confrontar la norma con qué es lo moralmente correcto asumiendo a su vez que siempre es posible determinar objetivamente esto último. Respecto de la discusión sobre la derrotabilidad de las normas jurídicas, señalo que la noción de &#8216;inderrotabilidad&#8217; resultante del análisis de Rodríguez deviene trivial desde el punto de vista práctico. Si se presenta un &#8216;problema epistémico&#8217; en la identificación de normas jurídicas excepcionantes (legal defeaters), el cual Rodríguez reconoce que podría existir &#8211;y cuyos posibles aspectos señalo y analizo&#8210;, entonces el dilema entre irracionalidad e irrelevancia podría persistir, aun dentro de los límites del positivismo jurídico.]]></p></abstract>
<abstract abstract-type="short" xml:lang="en"><p><![CDATA[Abstract I criticize Jorge Rodríguez&#8217;s claim that the dilemma between irrationality and irrelevance in following general norms and legal rules in particular, vanishes or loses its force if we give up confronting the rule with what is morally correct under the assumption that it is always possible to determine objectively the latter. In relation to the discussion on the defeasibility of legal rules, I claim that the notion of &#8216;indefeasibility&#8217; resulting from Rodríguez&#8217;s analysis becomes trivial from the practical point of view. If there is an &#8216;epistemic problem&#8217; in the identification of legal defeaters, as Rodríguez recognizes it could happen &#8211;I point out and analyze possible aspects of such problem&#8210; then the dilemma between irrationality and irrelevance could persist even within the frame of legal positivism.]]></p></abstract>
<kwd-group>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[irracionalidad]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[irrelevancia]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[normas jurídicas excepcionantes]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="es"><![CDATA[derrotabilidad]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="en"><![CDATA[irrationality]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="en"><![CDATA[irrelevance]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="en"><![CDATA[legal defeaters]]></kwd>
<kwd lng="en"><![CDATA[defeasibility]]></kwd>
</kwd-group>
</article-meta>
</front><back>
<ref-list>
<ref id="B1">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Alchourrón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[On Law and Logic]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Ratio Juris]]></source>
<year>1996</year>
<volume>9</volume>
<numero>4</numero>
<issue>4</issue>
<page-range>331-48</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B2">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Alchourrón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Philosophical foundations of deontic logic and the logic of defeasible conditionals]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Deontic logic in computer science: normative systems specification]]></source>
<year>1993</year>
<page-range>43-84</page-range><publisher-loc><![CDATA[Chichester ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Wiley]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B3">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Alchourrón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Bulygin]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Eugenio]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Normative Systems]]></source>
<year>1971</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Viena ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Springer-Verlag]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B4">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Alonso]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Juan Pablo]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Scataglini]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[María Gabriela]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Una crítica pragmática al realismo jurídico de P. Chiassoni]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Analisi e Diritto]]></source>
<year>2023</year>
<volume>2</volume>
<numero>X-X</numero>
<issue>X-X</issue>
<page-range>95-115</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B5">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Bayón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Juan Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Bulygin y la justificación de las decisiones judiciales: la partesorprendente]]></article-title>
<person-group person-group-type="editor">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Moreso]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[José Juan]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Redondo]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Cristina]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Un diálogo con la teoría del derecho de Eugenio Bulygin]]></source>
<year>2007</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Madrid ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Marcial Pons]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B6">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Bayón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Juan Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Derecho, convencionalismo y controversia]]></article-title>
<person-group person-group-type="editor">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Navarro]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Pablo]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Redondo]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Cristina]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[La relevancia del derecho. Ensayos de filosofía jurídica, moral y política]]></source>
<year>2002</year>
<page-range>57-92</page-range><publisher-loc><![CDATA[Barcelona ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Gedisa]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B7">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Bayón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Juan Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[¿Por qué es derrotable el razonamiento jurídico?]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Doxa. Cuadernos de Filosofía del Derecho]]></source>
<year>2001</year>
<numero>24</numero>
<issue>24</issue>
<page-range>35-62</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B8">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Bayón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Juan Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Derrotabilidad, indeterminación del derecho y positivismo jurídico]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Isonomía]]></source>
<year>2000</year>
<numero>13</numero>
<issue>13</issue>
<page-range>87-117</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B9">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Bayón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Juan Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Sobre la racionalidad de dictar y seguir reglas]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Doxa, Cuadernos de Filosofía del Derecho]]></source>
<year>1996</year>
<numero>19</numero>
<issue>19</issue>
<page-range>143-62</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B10">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Caracciolo]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Ricardo]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Normas Derrotables. La concepción de Carlos Alchourrón]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Análisis Filosófico]]></source>
<year>2006</year>
<volume>XXVI</volume>
<numero>1</numero>
<issue>1</issue>
<page-range>156-77</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B11">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Caracciolo]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Ricardo]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Una discusión sobre normas derrotables]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Discusiones]]></source>
<year>2005</year>
<numero>5</numero>
<issue>5</issue>
<page-range>87-100</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B12">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Celano]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Bruno]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[True Exceptions. Defeasibility and Particularism]]></article-title>
<person-group person-group-type="editor">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Ferrer]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Jordi]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Ratti]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Giovanni B.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[The Logic of Legal Requirements. Essays on Defeasibility]]></source>
<year>2012</year>
<page-range>268-87</page-range><publisher-loc><![CDATA[Oxford ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Oxford University Press]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B13">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Hart]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Herbert]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[The Concept of Law]]></source>
<year>1961</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Oxford ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Clarendon Press]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B14">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[MacCormick]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Neil]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Defeasibility in Law and Logic]]></article-title>
<person-group person-group-type="editor">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Bankowski]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Z.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[White]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[I.]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Hahn]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[U.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Informatics and the Foundations on Legal Reasoning]]></source>
<year>1995</year>
<page-range>99-117</page-range><publisher-loc><![CDATA[Dordrecht ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Kluwer]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B15">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Moreso]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[José Juan]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Rodríguez]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Jorge Luis]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Estudio introductorio. Carlos E. Alchourrón y la máxima de la mutilación mínima]]></article-title>
<person-group person-group-type="editor">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Alchourrón]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Carlos E.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Fundamentos para una teoría general de los deberes]]></source>
<year>2010</year>
<page-range>11-38</page-range><publisher-loc><![CDATA[Madrid ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Marcial Pons]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B16">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Moreso]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[José Juan]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Vilajosana]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Josep Maria]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Introducción a la teoría del derecho]]></source>
<year>2004</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Barcelona ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Marcial Pons]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B17">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Nino]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Carlos]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[El constructivismo ético]]></source>
<year>1989</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Madrid ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Centro de Estudios Constitucionales]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B18">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Raz]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Joseph]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Practical Reason and Norms]]></source>
<year>1999</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Oxford ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Oxford University Press]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B19">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Redondo]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Cristina]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Razones y normas]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Discusiones]]></source>
<year>2005</year>
<numero>5</numero>
<issue>5</issue>
<page-range>29-66</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B20">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Rodríguez]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Jorge Luis]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Teoría analítica del derecho]]></source>
<year>2021</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Madrid ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Marcial Pons]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B21">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Rodríguez]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Jorge Luis]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Against Defeasibility of Legal Rules]]></article-title>
<person-group person-group-type="editor">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Ferrer]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Jordi]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Ratti]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Giovanni B.]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[The Logic of Legal Requirements. Essays on Defeasibility]]></source>
<year>2012</year>
<page-range>89-107</page-range><publisher-loc><![CDATA[Oxford ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Oxford University Press]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B22">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Rodríguez]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Jorge Luis]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[La lógica de los sistemas jurídicos]]></source>
<year>2002</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Madrid ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B23">
<nlm-citation citation-type="journal">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Rodríguez]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Jorge Luis]]></given-names>
</name>
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Sucar]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Germán]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<article-title xml:lang=""><![CDATA[Las trampas de la derrotabilidad. Niveles de análisis de la indeterminación del derecho]]></article-title>
<source><![CDATA[Doxa, Cuadernos de Filosofía del Derecho]]></source>
<year>1998</year>
<numero>21</numero>
<issue>21</issue>
<page-range>403-20</page-range></nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B24">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Scataglini]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[María Gabriela]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Seguimiento de reglas: el &#8220;aguijón pragmático&#8221; en la teoría del derecho]]></source>
<year>2021</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Madrid ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Marcial Pons]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B25">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Schauer]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Frederick]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Playing by the Rules. A philosophical examination of rule-based-decision making in law and life]]></source>
<year>1991</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Oxford ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Oxford University Press]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B26">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Soeteman]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Arend]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Logic in Law]]></source>
<year>1989</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Dordrecht ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Kluwer Academic Publishers]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
<ref id="B27">
<nlm-citation citation-type="book">
<person-group person-group-type="author">
<name>
<surname><![CDATA[Wittgenstein]]></surname>
<given-names><![CDATA[Ludwig]]></given-names>
</name>
</person-group>
<source><![CDATA[Philosophical Investigations]]></source>
<year>1953</year>
<publisher-loc><![CDATA[Oxford ]]></publisher-loc>
<publisher-name><![CDATA[Basil Blackwell]]></publisher-name>
</nlm-citation>
</ref>
</ref-list>
</back>
</article>
