SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.7 número2Evaluación inicial de algunos aspectos de calidad del fruto de aguacate ‘Hass’ producido en tres regiones de MéxicoUso eficiente y recuperación aparente de nitrógeno en maíz forrajero en suelos diferentes índice de autoresíndice de materiabúsqueda de artículos
Home Pagelista alfabética de revistas  

Servicios Personalizados

Revista

Articulo

Indicadores

Links relacionados

  • No hay artículos similaresSimilares en SciELO

Compartir


Revista mexicana de ciencias agrícolas

versión impresa ISSN 2007-0934

Rev. Mex. Cienc. Agríc vol.7 no.2 Texcoco feb./mar. 2016

 

Articles

Production and nutritional value of forage fractions beardless wheats

Víctor Manuel Zamora Villa1  § 

Modesto Colín Rico1 

María Alejandra Torres Tapia1 

Armando Rodríguez García1 

Martha Alicia Jaramillo Sánchez1 

1Universidad Autónoma Agraria “Antonio Narro”. Calzada Antonio Narro Núm. 1923, Saltillo, Coahuila. C.P. 25315. Tel: 844 4110220. (modesto.colin@uaaan.mx; atorres_tapia@hotmail.com; armando_roga@hotmail.com; mar_jars@hotmail.com).


Abstract

Dairy areas like the Laguna region of Mexico require forage options that provide forage quality and more flexible rotation schemes. Twenty beardless wheat lines more witnesses Avena Cuauhtemoc, Triticale Eronga 83 and a beardless experimental barley (Narro 95) were evaluated using an alpha-lattice design with 3 replications during A-W in 2010-2011 in order to quantify the production of dry matter and nutritional value of their fractions. The experiment was planted manually, in furrows and dry using 120 kg ha-1, two irrigations and 118 days after sowing sampling forage performed manually applied, noting the phenological stage, cover and height plant. The sample of dried green forage under natural conditions until constant weight, recording the dry matter production and carrying out the separation of leaves, stems and spikes. Only wheat genotypes more producers, more oats and barley, homogenized dry matter of repetition and nutritional value for each fraction was determined. Additional analysis of variance and mean test field variables, with mean values of these variables and nutritional value of principal component analysis (ACP) was performed. The results for dry matter yield showed significant differences among the evaluated genotypes, with 16 of them in the first group of significance including barley. Oats was the least grain production due to lower recovery after the frost. Some wheat exceeded oats in crude protein content and other quality variables in all three fractions studied. The stage at court influenced the production and quality, detected by the ACP relations, with the first three component accounted for more than 70% of the variance and allowed visualization of the AN-220-09 genotypes and AN264-09, AN-226-09 showed similar behavior oats. These results suggest the existence of beardless wheats with similar oat quality, but with greater production, with the additional advantage that no sharp edges (beard) on the shank prevents lacerate the mucous membranes of animals. The greatest contribution of dry matter did the stems, followed by leaves and finally the ears. The spikes showed greater nutritional value than the leaves and stems.

Keywords: dry matter production; nutritional quality forage fractions; wheat edgeless

Resumen

Cuencas lecheras como la de la Región Lagunera de México requieren opciones forrajeras que proporcionen forraje de calidad y flexibilicen los esquemas de rotación. Veintisiete líneas imberbes de trigo más los testigos Avena Cuauhtémoc, Triticale Eronga 83 y una cebada forrajera experimental imberbe (Narro 95) se evaluaron usando un diseño alfalátice con 3 repeticiones durante el ciclo O-I 2010-2011 con el objetivo de cuantificar la producción de materia seca y el valor nutritivo de sus fracciones. El experimento se sembró manualmente, a chorrillo y en seco usando 120 kg ha-1, se aplicaron dos riegos de auxilio y a los 118 días después de la siembra se realizó el muestreo de forraje en forma manual, anotando la etapa fenológica, cobertura y altura de planta. La muestra de forraje verde se secó bajo condiciones naturales hasta alcanzar peso constante, registrando la producción de materia seca y procediendo a la separación de hojas, tallos y espigas. Solamente de los genotipos de trigo más productores, más avena y cebada, se homogenizó la materia seca de las repeticiones y se determinó el valor nutritivo para cada fracción. Adicional al análisis de varianza y prueba de medias de las variables de campo, con los valores medios de estas variables y las de valor nutritivo se realizó un análisis de componentes principales (ACP). Los resultados para rendimiento de materia seca mostraron diferencias significativas entre los genotipos evaluados, con 16 de ellos en el primer grupo de significancia incluyendo la cebada. La avena fue la menos productiva de los cereales debido a su menor recuperación después de la helada. Algunos trigos superaron a la avena en contenido de proteína cruda y otras variables de calidad en las tres fracciones estudiadas. La etapa al momento del corte influenció la producción y calidad, relaciones detectadas por el ACP que, con los tres primeros componente explicó más de 70% de la variación y permitió visualizar que los genotipos AN-220-09, AN-264-09 y AN-226-09 mostraron comportamiento similar a la avena. Dichos resultados sugieren la existencia de trigos imberbes con calidad similar a la de avena, pero con mayor producción, con la ventaja adicional de que la ausencia de aristas (barba) en la espiga evita lacerar las mucosas de los animales. El mayor aporte de materia seca lo hicieron los tallos, seguidos por las hojas y finalmente las espigas. Las espigas mostraron mayor valor nutritivo que las hojas y tallos.

Palabras clave: calidad nutritiva; fracciones de forraje; producción de materia seca; trigo sin aristas

Introduction

The Laguna Region is the main dairy basin of Mexico and at critical times such as winter period requires nutritional quality forage options enabling it to maintain production. In the north of the country recurrently drastic climate variations in winter, as the frozen registered on 3 and 4 February 2011 that wreaked havoc on domestic agriculture are presented. Cereals represent important alternatives to sustain livestock production have frost tolerance during vegetative development and its use has spread in recent years, using them grazing, green onions, henificado, chopped and silage. (Hughes et al., 1974; Flores et al., 1984; Colín et al., 2004).

During the spring and summer high evaporation occur in semi-arid areas as it is where the Laguna Region is located and an option to avoid is making planting in winter, which favors the use of cereals and legumes to meet the demand of adequate quality forage . It has been proposed that a wheat, triticale or barley fodder should be soft or preferably beardless beard cover pin (Flores, 1977), which will extend the period of harvest to milky-doughy or later stages grain, but represent a risk animal.

Cereals have characteristics that make them especially useful for fodder, producing high yields and are rich in protein, vitamins and carbohydrates, (Cherney and Marten, 1982; Cash et al., 2004), has been classified as a good quality forage resource calidad (Hart et al., 1971; Juskiw et al., 2000). Herrera (1999), referring to the quality forage sources mentioned that low quality forages are those whose percentage of neutral detergent fiber (FDN) is greater than 60%, acid detergent fiber (FDA) greater than 35%, net energy lactation (ENL) of less than 1.4 Mcal/kg. The protein content is an important dietary factor per se; so foods high in protein, are also considered high quality (Juskiw et al., 2000). In evaluating forage quality, Castro (1976) reports that in barley, oats, wheat and triticale, no difference in protein content between species, finding an average of 35 percent in the early stages of development and 7% in half seed head.

The maturity stage at harvest has the greatest effect on the biomass yield and quality of cereals (Cherney y Marten, 1982; Bergen et al., 1991). It increases performance and quality declines as the crop matures, although cereal quality can be maintained or improved when grain growth occurs (Khorasani et al., 1997; González, 2007).

In forages it is vital to consider the nutritional value, reporting a decrease in general the same as the plant matures (Juskiw et al., 2000). Thus, the increase of FDA and FDN has been reported in response to the advance grain maturity (Cherney et al., 1983). The leaves and spikes generally have higher digestibility and protein stems (Baron and Kibite, 1987) and therefore may contain higher forage quality, however, there are few studies on the nutritional value of these fractions is studied although in some of them and barley has been established that an increase of the energy value associated with a higher proportion of grain in stages grain maturity, which also favors the protein content and increases the quality indicators, due to dilution indigestible fiber from grain (Ben-Ghedalia et al., 1995; Juskiw et al., 2000).

Under these assumptions, the Program Grain UAAAN has developed new beardless wheat genotypes in order to provide good forage production options and quality, however the nutritional contribution of the fractions that make up the forage is unknown. To this end, the present study aimed to evaluate the dry matter production and nutritional value of its fractions (leaves, stems and spikes) in beardless wheat lines compared to witness different species (oats and barley) under the hypothesis that there are wheat genotypes that equal or exceed those witnesses in total dry forage production and nutritive value of its fractions within genotypes evaluated.

Materials and methods

Twenty-seven advanced lines of feed wheat beardless developed by the Grains Program UAAAN and commercial varieties: Oats cv. Cuauhtemoc and Triticale cv. Eronga-83 plus an experimental line beardless barley (Narro 95) were evaluated during the season autumn-winter 2010-2011 at the ranch "Las Vegas" town of Francisco I. Madero, Coahuila, using alph- lattice design with three replications.

Land preparation consisted of traditional work used for the establishment of small grains of winter in regions where it is grown under irrigation, being planted dry manually at a seed rate of 120 kg ha-1, using 60 units of nitrogen using urea as a source, plus 80 units of phosphorus using monoammonium phosphate (MAP) to meet the nutrient; the first auxiliary irrigation 60 units of nitrogen to the same source was applied. Weeds were controlled manually, and no insecticide or fungicide was applied. A 118 days after planting watering sampling of forage and the rest of the experimental plot was conducted was allowed to come to grain production. The approximate total film during the crop cycle was 40 cm.

The experimental plot consisted of 6.3 m2 (6 rows of 3 m length 0.35 m between rows), sampling 50 cm of one of the rows fully competitive, cutting at a height of 5 cm above the soil surface. plant height (height), forage yield (FV), phenological stage (stage) by the scale of Zadoks et al: when cutting the variables were recorded. (1974), and the percentage of land cover (COB); green fodder is dried in a covered sundeck until constant weight and then the production of dry matter or dry forage was determined in t ha-1 (PSTON) separating the feed into its components: leaves, stems and spikes. Forage samples of the materials and rendidores oats and barley witnesses were sent to the laboratory AGROLAB of Mexico, S. A. de C. V., based in Gomez Palacio, Durango, for compositional analysis, determining values: percentage of crude protein (PC), acid detergent fiber (FDA), neutral detergent fiber (NDF) and net energy for lactation (NEL) for each of the fractions leaf (H), stem (T) and pin (E), literal spiked to identify their respective values.

Field data were analyzed using an alpha-lattice (0.1), comparing averages with proof of DMS. With average values of field variables and the results of nutritional value principal component analysis (ACP) in order to analyze the structure of covariance and detect the association of variables and genotypes it was carried out following the methodology described by Johnson and Wichern (1988).

Results and discussion

The analysis of variance showed differences (p< 0.01) between genotypes for plant height, phenological stage at cutting production of fodder and its fractions, while coverage only significant differences (p< 0.05) were detected, of witnesses used, triticale showed the highest plant height of 118 cm being statistically equal to three lines beardless wheat, oats reached 83 cm being the genotype lower height recorded in the experiment, possibly because of lower recovery after registered on 2 and 3 february 2011, the overall average frost stood at 102 cm. When cutting fodder, triticale was at the beginning of grain formation (aqueous or maturity stage 71 of the sacale fo Zadoks et al., 1974), while barley was in step 74 (milky medium) behaving as earlier materials, meanwhile oats were in the issue stage of the pin (step 59); the mean of this variable is registered in 66 or flowering stage. Most coverage was achieved barley field, followed by several wheat in the same group of significance, triticale showed middle ground cover (75%), and oats (65%) who presented lower ground cover, probably because his poor recovery after frost.

In the production of dry matter (PSTON) 15 callow wheat lines were located along with barley in the first group of significance in the following order: AN- 326-09, AN-26899, AN-220-09, barley, AN-228-09- AN-264-09, AN-26399, AN-244-99, AN-258-99, AN-216-09, AN- 217-09, AN230-09, AN-251-99, AN.272-99, AN226-09 and AN-229-09 who produced more than 12.0 t ha-1 of dry matter. These genotypes, more oats and lines AN-209-09, AN-336-09 and AN-267-99 were considered for conducting analyzes nutritional value of fractions: leaf, stem and spigot. The mean of this variable was located in 13.32 t ha-1.

With respect to fractions of forage stems (PSTALLO) provided a 50.98% of the total dry matter, while the leaves (PSHOJA) and pins (PSESPIGA) contributed 36.11 and 12.91% respectively. Among the 16 materials that made up the first group of significance in the production of total dry forage increased production of PSTALLO the genotypes obtained: AN-326-09, AN-228-09, AN-268-99, AN-26399 and 220-09 and others, who produced statistically like barley and they outperformed oats. The 28 genotypes of the first group of significance to PSHOJA included barley, oats and genotypes as AN-220-09, AN-217-09, AN-33609, AN-216-09, AN-264-09 and AN-209-09; all visually selected for highest leaf. Regarding PSESPIGA only six genotypes (including triticale Eronga 83) joined the first group of significance highlighting genotypes AN-268-99, AN-326-09 and AN-228-09.

The results of the analysis showed that there bromatological beardless wheat lines with higher crude protein content of oats in fractions studied, as well as oats showed the stem 8.3% protein (PCT) was wheat with 10% of PCT; Oat showed a 11.1% protein in wheat leaves exhibiting exist to 17.2% protein in leaf (PCH). Similarly occurred with the protein content in the pin (PCE) where oats while 19% showed some wheats reached to 25.6%. Barley consistently showed higher amounts of PC oats in all fractions tested.

All species showed a similar trend in PC contents: fewest in the stalks, leaves and intermediate to higher spikes.

Acid detergent fiber stem (FDAT) and leaf (FDAH) something similar occurred in the studied species, with wheat beating oats in content, but in FDA Tang (fdae) several wheats showed lower content the oats. A trend prevailed in the cereals: more FAD in stems, leaves and lower intermediate in FAD in spikes.

Similar behavior presented neutral detergent fiber (FDN) for the listed fractions with beating wheat oats in stems (FDNT) and leaves (FDNH), while the pin (FDNE) only some wheats showed fewer this fiber (range 54.7 to 64.9%).

These quality components could be affected by phenological stage as shown by some materials have shown (Cherney y Marten, 1982; Bergen et al., 1991).

The contents of net energy for lactation were higher for both oat stalks (ENLT) and leaves (ENLH), but in the ENL Tang (ENLT) several beardless wheats the beat, no doubt because most phenological stage which allowed them to have grain in the ear and achieve more energy.

To jointly analyze the above variables by principal components, three components with which 71.7% of the total variance (Table 1) were retained explained. The first component contained 29.7% of the variance and explained the positive relationship with each other and with the component of net energy of lactation stem (ENLT), leaf (ENLH) and pin (ENLE) with crude protein pin (PCE) and stems (PCT), neutral detergent fiber shank (FDNE) and dry matter production of the sheet (PSHOJA), while the phenological stage (ETAPA), plant height (ALTURA), production Total dry matter (PSTON), dry matter production of stems and spikes (PSTALLO and PSESPIGA) fibers (FDAH, FDNT, FDNH) and land cover (COB) showed a positive association with each other but negative with the component; whereby said first component can be interpreted in terms of the change that occurs to advance phenological stage, reflecting higher production of dry matter but fodder become more fibrous and woody, reducing protein and energy content, as shown in Figure 1; and this component separates the fibrous and woody those higher protein content and high energy genotypes, higher production. This has been well established and documented for most fodder obtained with small grains (Stark and Wilkinson, 1992; Mc Cartney and Vaage, 1994; Royo et al., 1998; Carr et al., 1998), although overall, without explaining what happens in fractions that compose it.

Table 1 Correlation coefficients of each variable with the three principal components and acumulative variance explained. 

Variables Componente principal 1 Componente principal 2 Componente principal 3
PSTALLO -,779 ,308 ,489
PSHOJA ,323 -,383 ,662
PSESPIGA -,869 ,386 ,067
PSTON -,739 :226 ,564
ALTURA -,796 :104 -,009
СОВ -,388 -,045 ,691
ETAPA -,647 :534 -,081
PCT :578 -,097 ,717
FD AT -,279 -,285 -178
FDNT -,623 -,655 -,150
ENLT ,466 ,554 -:21o
PCH -,062 :651 ,522
FDAH -,524 -,741 :077
FDNH -,511 -,762 -,135
ENLH ,614 :562 -,182
PCE .388 -,748 ,428
FDAE ,295 -,499 -,505
FDNE ,219 -,713 -,035
ENLE ,467 -,417 ,425
Varianza del eigenvalor (%) 29.7 25.9 16.1
Varianza acumulada (%) 29.7 55 6 71.7

Figure 1 Distribution of the variables in the first two principal components. 

The second component contained 25.9% of the variance explained mainly negative relationship between the content of neutral detergent fiber in leaves and stems (FDNH and FDNE) protein spikes (PCE) and acid detergent fiber sheet with net energy lactation stems and leaves (ENLT and ENLH) phenological stage of materials (ETAPA) and the protein content of the sheet (PCH), suggesting that some of the materials showed high levels of energy and protein in the feeding fractions brought to advanced stages of the formation of grain presenting smaller and less protein fibers in the ear. This is true for some wheats habit similar to that of barley growth, the highest dry matter production is associated with lower fiber content (Table 1 and Figure 1). The third component contained 13.6% of the variance, mainly explaining the higher amount of crude protein in stems, leaves and spikes associated with the coverage and production, albeit on a smaller stage oats.

By plotting the genotypes in the plane spanned by the two main components (Figure 2) we can characterize partially by production and nutritional value, and the beardless wheat lines AN-230-09, AN-326-09, AN-268-99, AN-228-09, AN229-09 and AN-63-99 are high, early materials, excellent producers of dry matter (with a high proportion of spikes and stems) and good crude protein content in the leaves, but smaller crude protein stems and spikes, as well as lower energy and neutral detergent fiber in the combined shank with fewer leaves.

Figure 2 Distribution of genotypes in the first two principal components. 

Conversely, lines such as the AN-216-09, AN-217-09, AN-258-99, AN-267-99 and AN-336-09 spikes have higher protein content, with more energy and detergent fiber neutral, increased leaf production and higher protein content in the stem, but produce fewer pegs and stems which confers lower yield of total dry matter, have lower height, are more delayed and less protein content in leaves.

Genotypes as AN-244-99, AN-272-99, AN-52-99 and AN209-09 are materials with higher ground cover, but are more fibrous and less energy content.

Oats and barley for its part, along with the AN-220-09, AN-264-09 and AN-226-09 lines have more net energy for lactation in stems and leaves, lower acid detergent fiber content in all fractions forage and lower NDF content in stems and leaves (Figure 2). This group of wheat lines is interesting since they have similar production and quality oats and barley, with the additional advantage of the absence of edges in the ear, which would avoid damage to the mucous membranes of cattle. Oats location at the far right, indicating their higher energy value stems and leaves, but lower production and stage characteristics that differ from the rest of the materials evaluated is highlighted.

Conclusions

There beardless wheat lines that have adequate production and quality of forage, similar to oats and barley can be used in livestock feed. This provides an option to diversify and flexible schemes intensive forage production as in dairy areas. In cereals evaluated the greatest contribution of dry matter had it stems, followed by leaves and finally the ears. The spikes showed greater nutritional value than the leaves and stems.

Literatura citada

Baron, V. S. and Kibite, S. 1987. Relationships of maturity. height and morphological traits with whole-plant yield and digestibility of barley cultivars. Can. J. Plant. Sci. 67:1009-1017. [ Links ]

Ben-Ghedalia, D. A.; Kabala, A. and Miron, J. 1995. Composition and in-vitro digestibility of carbohydrates of wheat plant harvested at bloom and soft-dough stages. J. Sci. Food Agric. 68:111-116. [ Links ]

Bergen, W. G.; Byrem, T. M. and Grant, A. L. 1991. Ensiling characteristic of whole - crop small grains harvested at milk and dough stages. J. Anim. Sci. 69:1766-1774. [ Links ]

Carr, P. M.; Martin, G. B.; Caton, J. S. and Poland, W. W. 1998. Forage and nitrogen yield of barley-pea intercrops. Agron. J. 90:84. [ Links ]

Castro, A. L. 1976. Rendimiento y calidad forrajera de cinco cereales evaluados en diferentes estados de desarrollo vegetativo. Tesis de maestría Colegio de Postgraduados Montecillo, México. 49-53 pp. [ Links ]

Cash, S. D.; Staber, L. M. M.; Wichman, D. M. and Hensleigh, P. F. 2004. Forage yield, quality and nitrate concentration of barley grown under irrigation. Montana State University. 4 p. [ Links ]

Cherney, J. H. and Marten, G. C. 1982. Small grain crop forage potential: I. biological and chemical determinants of quality, and yield. Crop. Sci. 22:227-231. [ Links ]

Cherney, J. H.; Marten, G. C. and Goodrich, R. D. 1983. Rate and extent of cell wall digestion of total forage and morphological components of oats and barley. Crop Sci. 23:213-216. [ Links ]

Colín, R. M.; Lozano, A. J.; Martínez, G.; Zamora, V. M.; Santana, J. T. y Méndez, V. M. 2004. Producción de materia seca de líneas de cebada forrajera imberbe en cuatro ambientes y correlaciones entre algunos componentes del rendimiento de forraje. Resultados de investigación 2003. UAAAN. Buenavista, Saltillo, Coahuila, México. 93-101 pp. [ Links ]

Flores, M. J. A. 1977. Bromatología animal. Edición Limusa. México. 1096 p. [ Links ]

Flores, L. A.; Lizarraga, G. C. y Peñuri, F. J. M. 1984. Evaluación en la producción de forraje, valor nutritivo y calidad de ensilaje en diferentes especies de cereales. Téc. Pec. Méx. Suplento. 11 p. [ Links ]

González, C. I. 2007. Producción y calidad forrajera de líneas de cebada imberbe (Hordeum vulgare L.) en la Comarca Lagunera. Tesis Licenciatura. UAAAN. Buenavista, Saltillo, Coahuila, México. 82 p. [ Links ]

Hart, H. R.; Carlson, G. E. and McCloud, D. E. 1971. Cummulative effects of cutting management of forage yields and tiller densities of tall fescue and orchard grass. Agron. J. USA. 63(4):895-898 [ Links ]

Hughes, H. D.; Heath, M. E. y Metcalfe, D. S. 1974. Forrajes, Ed. CECSA, México. 343-373 p. [ Links ]

Herrera, S. R. 1999. La importancia de los maíces y sorgos mejorados para la producción de forraje. En: Segundo taller nacional de especialidades de maíz. UAAAN. Saltillo, Coahuila, México. 138 p. [ Links ]

Juskiw, P. E.; Helm, J. H. and Salmon, D. F. 2000. Forage yield and quality for monocrops and mixtures of small grain cereals. Crop Sci. 40:138-147. [ Links ]

Jhonson, R. A. and Wichern, D. W. 1988. Applied multivariate statistical analysis. Second edition. Englewood Cliffs, NJ, USA: PrenticeHall. 607 p. [ Links ]

Khorasani, G. R.; Bedel, P. E.; Helm, J. H. and Kennelly, J. J. 1997. Influence of stage of maturation on yield components and chemical composition of cereal grain silages. Can. J. Anim. Sci. 77:259-267. [ Links ]

Mc Cartney, D. H. and Vaage, A. S. 1994. Comparative yield and feeding value of barley, oat and triticale silage. Can J. Anim. Sci. 74:91-96. [ Links ]

Royo, C.; Serra, J.; Puigdomench, A. and Aragay, M. 1998. Yield and quality of triticale cv. Trujillo and barley cv. Flika grown for different end-uses in a Mediterranean environment. Cereal Res. Comm. 26(2):169-176. [ Links ]

Stark, B. A. and Wilkinson, J. M. 1992. Whole crop cereals. Second edition. Chalcombe publications. United Kingdom. 175 p. [ Links ]

Zadoks, J. C.; Chang, T. T. and Konzak, C. F. 1974. A decimal code for the growth stages of cereals. Eucarpia Bulletin 7:42-52. [ Links ]

Received: August 2015; Accepted: January 2016

Creative Commons License Este es un artículo publicado en acceso abierto bajo una licencia Creative Commons