versión impresa ISSN 0187-3180
Rev. Mex. Mic vol.26 Xalapa jun. 2008
Verticillium fungicola var. fungicola: comparison of some Mexican and French isolates
Comparación de algunas cepas mexicanas y francesas de Verticillium fungicola var. fungicola
Michèle L. Largeteau1,*, Gerardo Mata2, JeanMichel Savoie1
1 INRA (Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique), UPR1264 Mycologie et Sécurité des Aliments, F33883 Villenave d 'Ornon, France.
2 Unidad de Micología, Instituto de Ecología, Km 2.5 antigua carretera a Coatepec, Xalapa 91000, Veracruz, México
* Autor para correspondencia: firstname.lastname@example.org
Recibido 18 de octubre 2007
Aceptado 25 de junio 2008
Isolates of Verticillium fungicola collected in 2002 in the Veracruz State, Mexico, and previously identified as V. fungicola var. fungicola, were compared to French isolates for genetic polymorphism and diversity in some physiological traits. Results were analysed based on studies of a larger group of European V. fungicola var. fungicola. RAPD analyses showed that Mexican isolates were genetically similar to those collected in Western Europe over the period 19872000. Mycelial growth rate, antibiosis effect against their host Agaricus bisporus, and in vitro sensitivity to the fungicide chlorothalonil did not distinguish the Mexican isolates from the European isolates studied.
Key words: Agaricus bisporus, edible mushroom, fungal pathogen, genetic diversity, physiological variability.
Se compararon cepas de Verticillium fungicola recolectadas en 2002 en el Estado de Veracruz, México, previamente identificadas como V. fungicola var. fungicola, con cepas francesas para observar su diversidad de polimorfismo genético y algunos aspectos fisiológicos. Los resultados se analizaron tomando en cuenta estudios con un mayor número de cepas europeas de V. fungicola var. fungicola. Los análisis de RAPD muestran que las cepas mexicanas son genéticamente similares a aquellas colectadas en el Oeste de Europa en el período 19872000. El crecimiento micelial, el efecto de antibiosis contra su hospedero Agaricus bisporus y la sensibilidad in vitro al fungicida chlorothalonil no permiten distinguir las cepas mexicanas de las europeas.
Palabras clave: Agaricus bisporus, hongos comestibles, hongos patógenos, diversidad genética, variabilidad fisiológica.
The ascomycete Verticillium fungicola (Preuss) Hassebrauk, responsible for dry bubble disease on Agaricus bisporus (Lange) Imbach, causes important losses worldwide in the mushroom industry. Two varieties of the pathogen have been identified; currently V. fungicola var. aleophilum affects mushroom crops in Canada and USA (Collopy et al., 2001). The variety fungicola is responsible for the disease in the Netherlands, Spain and France (Desrumeaux and Sedeyn, 2001; Gea et al., 2003; Largeteau et al., 2006). Thus, when we identified Mexican isolates collected in 2002 in the state of Veracruz as V. fungicola var. fungicola from their ITS15,8SITS2 region, we theorised that they may have originated from Europe (Largeteau et ah, 2004). The aim of the present study was to compare these Mexican isolates to four French isolates previously characterised for genetic polymorphism (Largeteau et al., 2006), some physiological traits and pathogenicity
Material and Methods
Isolates of Verticillium fungicola
All isolates were isolated from bubbles and were identified as V. fungicola var. fungicola (Largeteau et al., 2004, 2006). Isolates VMX1, VMX2 and VMX3 were collected in 2002 in the state of Veracruz (Mexico); isolates VCF, VCTC, VF and VK were collected over the period of 19871997 at French mushroom farms. Prior to this study, all fungi were maintained on a malt extract agar medium (1% malt, 1.5 % agar) at 4 °C in darkness.
Genomic DNA was extracted from freezedried mycelium with the Nucleon Phytopure extraction kit RPN 8510 (Amersham International, Little Chalfort) according to the manufacturer procedure. Amplification was performed in a 25 µl reaction mixture containing 0.1 mM dNTPs, 1X DynAzymeTM fuffer (Finnzymes, Espoo, Finland), 0.8 U DynAzymeTM II polymerase, 0.5 µM decamer primer, 5 µg DNA. The crocodile III Thermal Cycler (Appligene, Illkirch, France) was programmed for one cycle of 6 min at 94 °C; 35 cycles of 1 min at 93 °C, 2 min at 36 °C, 2 min at 72 °C, with a final extension period of 6 min at 72 °C. Primers OPA03, OPA11, OPA18, OPD04, OPD18, OPZ10, OPZ20 (Life Technologies, CergyPontoise, France) and UBC29 (University of British Columbia) were screened. Each RAPD was performed twice. Numeric images of agarose gels were recorded and the presence or absence of RAPD products was scored with the Kodak Digital Science 1DTM analyser.
Mycelial growth rate
All Verticillium fungicola isolates were cultivated at 23 °C on a malt extract agar medium (MEA: 10 g l1 malt extract and 15 g l1 agar). All inocula were 10d old. The colony's growth (two perpendicular diameters) was measured daily, and the growth rate per day was calculated for the period of linear growth. Five replicates were prepared for each strain. The experiment was performed twice.
In vitro antibiosis
Double layer cultures were used to assess the effect of diffusible or volatile compounds produced by A. bisporus on the germination and colony extension of V. fungicola, and the effect of the pathogen on the development of the colony of the basidiomycete. An offwhite commercial strain of Agaricus bisporus (2100 Amycel, France) was cultivated on a MEA medium until the colony reached 4 cm in diameter. Afterwards, an agar medium (1.2 g l1 bactopeptone, 6 g l1sodium pyrophosphate and 15 g l1 agar) containing 106 conidia of V. fungicola, maintained at 50 °C, was poured over a growing colony of A. bisporus. The cultures were incubated at 23 °C for 9 d before the surface area covered by V. fungicola colonies was recorded drawing the limits of mycelia on the Petri dish cover. The surface area covered by the mycelium of A. bisporus after the supply of the pathogen was also calculated drawing the limits of mycelia on the bottom Petri dish. Drawings were photocopied on tracing paper calibrated at 70 g cm1, cut off and weighted to determine the surface. Five replicates were prepared for the V. fungicola strains. The experiment was performed twice.
In vitro susceptibility to chlorothalonil
The commercial fungicide Banko® (Chlorothalonil, produced in Calliope, Pau, France) was added to the MEA medium just before it was poured into Petri dishes. Cultures of V. fungicola on media containing 0, 20, 200, 400, 800 and 4000 ppm chlorothalonil were grown at 23 °C for 19 days.
Colonies were measured daily (two perpendicular diameters), and their growth rate as compared to the control (unamended medium) was calculated at the beginning and at the end of the period of linear growth. Two experiements were performed, each with five replicate per isolate and concentration of fungicide. To observe the adaptation of the pathogen to the fungicide, inocula removed from the MEA medium with and without chlorothalonil (20 ppm) were placed on a MEA medium containing 20 ppm of chlorothalonil. The colonies diameters were compared after 19 d at 23 °C. Five replicates were performed for each condition.
Eight freshly harvested sporophores of studied strain of A. bisporus were placed into a moist chamber, and received 20 µl of a conidial suspension of V. fungicola (106 conidia ml1) on the cap surface. The diameter and the depth of the necrosis were recorded using a vernier after 5 d of incubation at 20 °C. The experiment was performed twice.
Data were analysed using the SAS, Inc PROC ANOVA procedure (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC) and the means were separated, if necessary, using the StudentNewmanKeuls test at 95% level.
Results and discussion
The seven isolates studied had all been previously identified as V. fungicola var. fungicola (Largeteau et al., 2004). An analysis of their genetic variability was performed at this point. Data of RAPD obtained from eight primers, selected for their ability to discriminate among V. fungicola isolates (Largeteau et al., 2006), demonstrated that the Mexican isolates are genetically very similar to the isolates collected in France over the period of 19872000 (Figure 1). In these previous studies we identified a non polymorphic group of European (France, NL, UK) isolates collected between 1987 and 2000, from which VF and VK were representatives, and found that VCTC and VCF showed polymorphism (presence or absence of a single band) with one and nine primers out of 24, respectively. In the present study, primers OPA03, OPD18, OPZ20 and UBC 29 gave identical RAPD profiles for the Mexican and the French isolates. Three primers (OPA11, OPA18 and OPD04) grouped the three Mexican isolates with VCF, VF and VK and separated them from VCTC, which showed a single extra band. With primer OPZ10 only isolate VMX1 showed polymorphism with a different band (Figure 1). Two of the Mexican isolates can be grouped with the non polymorphic group of isolates described previously, and the third isolate, even very close to this group, presents a specific genetic marker. These observations are in agreement with our previous hypothesis of a European origin.
In addition to the genetic polymorphism, phenotypic characterisation of the isolates is of interest. For instance, there was the question of the pathogenic potential of the Mexican isolates. Mycelial growth rate is one of the components of this potential. The mycelium growth rate of isolate VMX1 differed from VMX2 and VMX3 at 23 °C. The French isolate VCTC had maximum growth rate and it was different to all other isolates. However, considering VCTC apart, French and Mexican isolates did not differ on mycelial growth (Table 1), with values close to those observed for other European isolates (Largeteau et al., 2006).
The consequences of interspecific interactions on spore germination and mycelial radial growth are another component of the pathogenic power of V. fungicola. The mutual effects of host and pathogen were observed in vitro. The diffusible or/and volatile compounds produced by A. bisporus 2100 had similar effect on the germination and the mycelial growth of all the isolates of V. fungicola, except for the VCF strain, which exhibited the lower mycelial extension. The effect of V. fungicola on A. bisporus mycelial growth was also measured. The Mexican isolates were measured against two French isolates (VCF and VK) for this effect. These five isolates were far less effective than VCTC and VF in reducing the development of the mycelium of A. bisporus (Table 1).
The virulence test for estimating the ability of each V. fungicola to infest the mushroom was the last component of the pathogenic potential measured. The three Mexican isolates were virulent; however French isolates induced necrosis on the cap of the sporophore having significantly higher diameters, while depth necrosis induced by Mexican isolates was significantly higher than French isolates, except for the most virulent VCTC (Table 1). Taking into account the different data presented here, the Mexican isolates appeared to have a middle pathogenic potential close to most of the French isolates used here as a representative sample of European isolates previously analysed (Largeteau et al., 2006). Their studied physiological traits did not differ significantly from the French isolates, except for virulence. However, we have postulated that inoculation directly on the pilei gives information on the virulence, but is more valuable in classifying A. bisporus strains for their susceptibility to the disease, than V. fungicola isolates for their potential as pathogen.
Comparative pathogenicity tests, including VMX1, were performed in previous studies and gave information on this Mexican isolate. It resulted from these cropping tests that VMX1, VCTC and the Dutch isolate V9503 induced similar percentages of bubbles, spotty caps and stipe blowout (Largeteau et ah, 2005). This level of agressiveness is relatively high among the V. fungicola var. fungicola, but it is lower than that of V. fungicola var. aleophilum. Inoculation of eight strains of A. bisporus with five isolates of V. fungicola in an other experiment revealed that V9503 and an unnamed isolate of V. fungicola var. fungicola were significantly less aggressive (regardless of symptoms), than three isolates tested of V. fungicola var. aleophilum, which were representative of the clonal population responsible for the outbreak of the dry bubble disease in Pennsylvania (USA) at the end of the 1990s (Collopy et al., 2001).
The increasing resistance of V. fungicola to fungicides is well known, and adaptation to such chemicals was proposed as an important factor on the decrease of pathogen variability (Bonnen & Hopkins, 1997). The susceptibility of Mexican and French isolates to chlorothalonil was compared. Data showed that at the beginning of the period of linear growth (d 5), the Mexican isolates differed in susceptibility to 20, 200 and 4000 ppm of fungicide, but whatever the concentration in fungicide, their susceptibility level was statistically the same as at least one French isolate. At the 19ª day of growth (the end of the period of linear growth), variability in susceptibility was observed both within the Mexican and the French isolates, and both groups of isolates exhibited a similar level of susceptibility irrespective of the concentration in fungicide. Except for VMX3, the susceptibility to concentration in chlorothalonil was lower at 19 d and the strains showed a higher percentage of growth (Table 2). Testing for adaptation of V. fungicola to the fungicide in vitro showed that, compared to a preculture without fungicide, a preculture on a MEA medium, with 20 ppm of chlorothalonil added, had no significant effect on the mycelial growth of isolates VK and VMX2 on a new MEA medium with fungicide. In contrast, the preculture with fungicide induced the adaptation of four isolates (VCF, VF, VMX1 and VMX3) to this concentration in chlorothalonil, and the same treatment increased the susceptibility of VCTC to the fungicide (Table 3). This relatively high resistance to the fungicide tends to indicate that the Mexican isolates were derived from European strains imported after an increasing level of resistance had developed.
The isolates of V. fungicola var. fungicola collected in the State of Veracruz in 2002 did not differ significantly from isolates of the same variety originating from Western Europe, and can be distinguished from the clonal population of Pennsylvania by both the variety and a lesser aggressiveness (Largeteau et al., 2006).
The procedures for A. bisporus cultivation in the Mexican region where the V. fungicola strains were collected are much closer to the European ones than to the US ones, which could explain why the Mexican isolates are very similar to the French and Dutch isolates. Another explanation is that the physiology traits of V. fungicola depend for the major part on the variety. The similarity between the four isolates from Western Europe and the three Mexican isolates supports the European origin we hypothesised for the latter (Largeteau et al., 2004). But considering differences among Mexican isolates in the various criteria studied, we question the possibility of several introductions or variability acquired after introduction.
This work was supported by the cooperation programme FranceMexico ECOS/ANUIES, M06A01.
Bonnen A.M., C. Hopkins, 1997. Fungicide resistance and population variation in Verticillium fungicola, a pathogen of the button mushroom, Agaricus bisporus. Mycological Research 101: 8996. [ Links ]
Collopy, P.D., M.L. LargeteauMamoun, C.P. Romaine, D.J. Royse, 2001. Molecular phylogenetic analyses of Verticillium fungicola and related species causing dry bubble disease of the cultivated button mushroom,Agaricus bisporus. Phytopathology 91:905912. [ Links ]
Desrumeaux, B., P. Sedeyn, 2001. Resistance of dry bubbles (Verticillium fungicola var. fungicola) to prochloraz 2nd series. Champignonberichten 191: 811. [ Links ]
Gea, F.J., J.C. Tello, M.J. Navarro, 2003. Occurrence of Verticillium fungicola var. fungicola on Agaricus bitorquis mushroom crops in Spain. Journal of Phytopathology 151: 98100. [ Links ]
Largeteau, M.L., J.P.P. Baars, C. RegnaultRoger, J.M. Savoie, 2006. Molecular and physiological diversity among Verticillium fungicola var. fungicola. Mycological Research 110:431440. [ Links ]
Largeteau, M.L., G. Mata, J.M. Savoie, 2004. Verticillium fungicola var. fungicola affects Agaricus bisporus cultivation in Mexico. FEMS MIcrobiology Letters 236:191196. [ Links ]
Largeteau, M.L., J.P.P. Baars, S. Juarez del Carmen, C. Regnault Roger, J.M. Savoie, 2005. Wild strains of Agaricus bisporus: a source of tolerance to dry bubble disease. In: Pisabarro A.G., L.Ramírez (eds.), Genetics and Cellular Biology of Basidiomycetes. Universidad Pública de Navarra, Pamplona, pp. 7787. [ Links ]